“The Samurai and the Prisoner”: Kiyoshi Kurosawa Moves From a World of Dread Toward the Possibility of Hope

Writing in MUBI Notebook, Alexis Moon uses Kiyoshi Kurosawa's new film The Samurai and the Prisoner to argue that the Japanese filmmaker should be understood as far more than the "horror master" label often attached to him. From Cure and Pulse to Tokyo Sonata and Cloud, much of Kurosawa's cinema has examined alienation, fractured identity, technology, and the social and economic aftermath of Japan's Lost Decades. His new film, however, marks an important shift. Rather than simply diagnosing what is broken in the modern world, Kurosawa begins to imagine how its underlying rules might be changed. Set during the Sengoku period and the second siege of Arioka Castle in 1578–79, the film centers on the historical samurai lord Araki Murashige, played by Masahiro Motoki, who rebelled against Oda Nobunaga, and Kuroda Kanbei, the celebrated strategist sent to persuade him to surrender, in what the critic calls an astounding performance by Suda Masaki. Murashige instead imprisons Kanbei, beginning a prolonged contest of wills that gradually moves beyond military victory toward questions of tradition, power, and the possibility of choosing another path. In Moon's reading, Murashige becomes a figure through whom Kurosawa challenges the very framework in which victory and defeat are understood. The film also enters into a dialogue with the legacy of Akira Kurosawa, particularly Throne of Blood and Kagemusha; both Kurosawas made their samurai film at seventy. Yet where Akira Kurosawa could look toward the samurai as a lost heroic ideal, Kiyoshi Kurosawa centers an almost anti-samurai figure whose significance lies in his willingness to reject inherited rules. Violence largely occurs offscreen and is never glorified, while long takes, sliding doors, shifting architectural spaces, and constantly changing allegiances create an intricate web of deception and power. Most significantly, the film ends on a note unlike the darker conclusions of many earlier Kurosawa works. Wind moving through the trees becomes an image of something invisible whose existence can nevertheless be felt; Kurosawa himself has said he thinks of cinema as something there for us to capture the wind. After decades spent examining alienation and social breakdown, The Samurai and the Prisoner suggests a filmmaker no longer content merely to expose a damaged world, but newly interested in imagining the conditions under which a different one might become possible.

Read the full story at MUBI Notebook →