On Joan Didion and the Art of Looking Back

In this essay, Maggie McKinley examines the place of nostalgia in the work of Joan Didion. The piece opens with Thomas Wolfe's novel You Can't Go Home Again, where returning to home and to the past is no longer possible, and where, after confronting the upheavals of the world, a person cannot go back to their former way of seeing. The author then ties this question to Didion's work. In her view, few contemporary American writers have examined the complexity of nostalgia, in both personal and collective life, as deeply as Didion. Across her fiction and nonfiction, Didion returns again and again to the meaning of home, the past, and memory, yet she never presents the past as a flawless, golden image. She is aware of both the pull of looking back and its dangers. The essay shows that nostalgia in Didion's work is neither simple nor merely conservative. The feeling can sometimes trap a person in the past, and at other times become a tool for understanding the present. Didion looks back in order to see how memory is constructed, and how individuals and societies build stories about themselves. The author notes that from her first novel, Run River, to The Year of Magical Thinking, Didion grappled with the question of return and the impossibility of return. Her famous remark that we tell ourselves stories in order to live is read within this same framework. In this view, the question is not only what we remember. What matters more is how we remember, and what that manner of remembering says about us and our time. In closing, McKinley emphasizes that nostalgia in Didion's work can be both paralyzing and illuminating. Used without question, at a political or institutional level, it turns into myth and delusion. But when it is paired with doubt and self-awareness, it can become a path toward understanding personal truths and cultural and national myths.

Read the full story at LitHub →