Criticism of the Book "Nazare bar Nazar," a Collection of Book Reviews

This article is a critical review of Nazar bar Nazar, a work by Seyyed Ali Kashfi Khansari consisting of twelve book reviews, a pathology of publishing theoretical children's literature works, and a response to critical feedback. The review examines the book in two parts: the first addresses its overall structural and content, while the second analyzes each article individually according to book review principles. The article identifies several deficiencies including the absence of a comprehensive introduction, problematic page numbering in the index, lack of logical foundation for many claims, insufficient examples to support arguments, and incomplete or missing citations.